The Sports Emmy Awards for Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Analyst and Outstanding Sports Personality, Sports Event Analyst made their debuts at the awards show in different years — 1993 for the Studio Analyst award and 1997 for the Sports Event Analyst award. Before 1993, an Emmy was awarded in just one combined category. That list of winners will also be featured here.
Studio Analyst
- 1993: Billy Packer (CBS)
- 1994: John Madden (FOX)
- 1995: John Madden (2) (FOX)
- 1996: Howie Long (FOX)
- 1997: Cris Collinsworth (HBO/NBC)
- 1998: Cris Collinsworth (2) (HBO/FOX)
- 1999: Terry Bradshaw (FOX)
- 2000: Steve Lyons (FOX)
- 2001: Terry Bradshaw (2) (FOX)
- 2002: Cris Collinsworth (3) (HBO)
- 2003: Cris Collinsworth (4) (HBO)
- 2004: Cris Collinsworth (5) (HBO)
- 2005: Cris Collinsworth (6) (HBO)
- 2006: Cris Collinsworth (7) (HBO/NBC)
- 2007: Cris Collinsworth (8) (HBO/NBC)
- 2008: Terry Bradshaw (3) (FOX) / Tom Jackson (ESPN)
- 2009: Kirk Herbstreit (ESPN)
- 2010: Kirk Herbstreit (2) (ESPN)
- 2011: Charles Barkley (CBS/NBA TV/TNT)
- 2012: Charles Barkley (2) (NBA TV/TNT)
- 2013: Harold Reynolds (MLB Network/FOX) / Tom Verducci (TBS/MLB Network)
- 2014: Harold Reynolds (2) (MLB Network)
- 2015: Bill Ripken (MLB Network)
- 2016: Charles Barkley (3) (CBS/TBS/TNT/truTV)
- 2017: Harold Reynolds (3) (MLB Network)
- 2018: Harold Reynolds (4) (MLB Network)
- 2019: Kirk Herbstreit (3) (ESPN)
- 2020: Charles Barkley (4) (CBS/TBS/TNT/tryTV)
Sports Event Analyst
- 1997: Joe Morgan (ESPN)
- 1998: John Madden (FOX)
- 1999: John Madden (2) (FOX)
- 2000: Tim McCarver (FOX)
- 2001: Tim McCarver (2) (FOX)
- 2002: Tim McCarver (3) (FOX)
- 2003: John Madden (3) (ABC)
- 2004: Joe Morgan (2) (ESPN)
- 2005: John Madden (4) (ABC)
- 2006: Cris Collinsworth (NFL Network)
- 2007: John Madden (5) (NBC)
- 2008: Cris Collinsworth (2) (NFL Network/NBC)
- 2009: Cris Collinsworth (3) (NBC)
- 2010: Cris Collinsworth (4) (NBC)
- 2011: Cris Collinsworth (5) (NBC)
- 2012: Cris Collinsworth (6) (NBC)
- 2013: Cris Collinsworth (7) (NBC)
- 2014: Cris Collinsworth (8) (NBC)
- 2015: Bill Raftery (CBS/Fox Sports 1/TBS/TNT/truTV)
- 2016: Bill Raftery (2) (CBS/Fox Sports 1/TBS/TNT/truTV)
- 2017: Kirk Herbstreit (ESPN/ABC)
- 2018: Bill Raftery (3) (CBS/Fox Sports 1/TBS/TNT/truTV)
- 2019: Bill Raftery (4) (CBS/Fox Sports 1/TBS/TNT/truTV)
- 2020: Kirk Herbstreit (2) (ESPN/ABC)
Outstanding Analyst
- 1981: Dick Button (ABC)
- 1982: John Madden (CBS)
- 1983: John Madden (2) (CBS)
- 1984: no award was given
- 1985: no award was given
- 1986: no award was given
- 1987: John Madden (3) (CBS)
- 1988: John Madden (4) (CBS)
- 1989: John Madden (5) (CBS)
- 1990: John Madden (6) (CBS)
- 1991: John Madden (7) (CBS)
- 1992: John Madden (8) (CBS)