| Year | Champion(s) | Record | Coach | Selector(s) |
| 1910 | Oak Park, IL | 10–2 | Robert Zuppke | NSNS |
| 1911 | Oak Park, IL | 10–0 | Robert Zuppke | NSNS |
| 1912 | Oak Park, IL | 10–0 | Robert Zuppke | NSNS |
| 1913 | Oak Park, IL | 10–1 | Glenn Thistlewaite | NSNS |
| 1914 | Everett, MA | 13–0 | Cleo O'Donnell | NSNS |
| 1915 | Detroit, MI, Central | 11–0–1 | Edbert C. Buss | NSNS |
| Everett, MA | 11–0–1 | Cleo O'Donnell | NSNS |
| 1916 | San Diego, CA | 12-0 | Nibs Price | NSNS |
| 1917 | No Award Made | | | |
| 1918 | Harrisburg, PA, Tech | 9–0 | Paul Smith | NSNS |
| 1919 | Harrisburg, PA, Tech | 12–0 | Paul Smith | NSNS |
| 1920 | Everett, WA | 9–0–1 | Enoch Bagshaw | NSNS |
| Oak Park, IL | 9–0–1 | Glenn Thistlewaite | NSNS |
| 1921 | Jacksonville, FL, Duval | 8–0 | Wiley Wright | NSNS |
| 1922 | Toledo, OH, Scott | 9–0 | Dr. William A. Neill | NSNS |
| 1923 | East Cleveland, OH, Shaw | 9–1 | John Snavely | NSNS |
| Toledo, OH, Scott | 10–0 | Dr. William A. Neill | NSNS |
| 1924 | Toledo, OH, Waite | 10–0 | Joe C. Collins | NSNS |
| 1925 | Pine Bluff, AR | 16–0 | Foy Hammons | NSNS |
| 1926 | Tuscaloosa, AL | 9–0 | Paul Burnum | NSNS |
| 1927 | Waco, TX | 14–0 | Paul Tyson | NSNS |
| 1928 | Medford, OR | 9–0 | Prink Callison | NSNS |
| 1929 | Tuscaloosa, AL | 9–0 | Paul Burnum | NSNS |
| 1930 | Phoenix, AZ, Union | 13–0 | R.R. Robinson | NSNS |
| 1931 | Ashland, KY | 10–0 | Paul Jenkins | NSNS |
| 1932 | Toledo, OH, Waite | 12–0 | Donald McCallister | NSNS |
| 1933 | Oklahoma City, OK, Capitol Hill | 12–0 | Jim Lookabaugh | NSNS |
| 1934 | Canton, OH, McKinley | 11–0 | Jimmy Aiken | NSNS |
| 1935 | Massillon, OH, Washington | 10–0 | Paul Brown | NSNS |
| 1936 | Massillon, OH, Washington | 10–0 | Paul Brown | NSNS |
| 1937 | Chicago, IL, Austin | 10–0 | William Heiland | NSNS |
| 1938 | Louisville, KY, Manual | 10–0 | Ray Baer | LSA,[2] NSNS |
| 1939 | Massillon, OH, Washington | 10–0 | Paul Brown | NSNS |
| Pine Bluff, AR | 11–0–1 | Allen Dunaway | LSA[2] |
| Garfield, NJ | 10–0 | Art Argauer | NSC[3] |
| 1940 | Massillon, OH, Washington | 10–0 | Paul Brown | NSNS |
| 1941 | Chicago, IL, Leo | 11–0 | Whitey Cronin | NSNS |
| 1942 | Miami, FL | 9–0 | Lyles Alley | NSNS |
| 1943 | Miami, FL | 9–0 | Tom Moore | NSNS |
| 1944 | No Award Made | | | |
| 1945 | No Award Made | | | |
| 1946 | Little Rock, AR, Senior | 14–0 | Raymond Burnett | NSNS |
| 1947 | East Chicago, IN, Roosevelt | 9–0 | Pete Rucinski [1] | NSNS |
| Lynn, MA, Classical | 11–1 | Bill Joyce [2] | NSNS |
| 1948 | Waco, TX | 14–0 | Carl Price | NSNS |
| 1949 | Wichita Falls, TX | 14–0 | Joe Golding | NSNS |
| 1950 | Massillon, OH, Washington | 10–0 | Chuck Mather | NSNS |
| 1951 | Weymouth, MA | 9–0 | Harry Arlanson [3] | NSNS |
| 1952 | Massillon, OH, Washington | 10–0 | Chuck Mather | NSNS |
| 1953 | Massillon, OH, Washington | 10–0 | Chuck Mather | NSNS |
| 1954 | Vallejo, CA | 9–0 | Bob Patterson | NSNS |
| 1955 | San Diego, CA | 12–0 | Duane Maley | NSNS |
| 1956 | Abilene, TX | 14–0 | Charles Moser | NSNS |
| 1957 | Little Rock, AR, Central | 12–0 | Wilson Matthews | NSNS |
| Portland, OR, Jefferson | 11–0 | Thomas DeSylvia | NSNS |
| 1958 | Portland, OR, Jefferson | 11–0 | Thomas DeSylvia | NSNS |
| 1959 | Massillon, OH, Washington | 10–0 | Leo Strang | NSNS |
| 1960 | Lawrence, KS | 9–0 | Al Woolard | NSNS |
| 1961 | Massillon, OH, Washington | 11–0 | Leo Strang | NSNS |
| 1962 | Valdosta, GA | 12–0 | Wright Bazemore | NSNS |
| Miami, FL | 9–0 | Ottis Mooney | ISSOC |
| 1963 | Chicago, IL, St. Rita | 9–0 | Edward Buckley | NSNS |
| 1964 | Coral Gables, FL | 12–0 | Nick Kotys | NSNS |
| 1965 | Miami, FL | 12–0 | Robert Carlton | NSNS |
| 1966 | Pico Rivera, CA, El Rancho | 13–0 | Ernest Johnson | NSNS |
| 1967 | Austin, TX, Reagan | 14–0 | Travis Raven | NSNS |
| Coral Gables, FL | 13–0 | Nick Kotys | NSNS |
| 1968 | Austin, TX, Reagan | 15–0 | Travis Raven | NSNS |
| 1969 | Pasadena, CA, Blair | 13–0 | Pete Yoder | NSNS |
| 1970 | Reagan, Austin, Texas | 14–1 | Travis Raven | NSNS |
| 1971 | Valdosta, GA | 13–0 | Wright Bazemore | NSNS |
| 1972 | Bristol, TN | 13–0 | John Cropp | NSNS |
| Odessa, TX, Permian | 14–0 | Gil Bartosh | NSNS |
| 1973 | Chattanooga, TN, Baylor | 13–0 | E. B. "Red" Etter | NSNS |
| Tyler, TX,John Tyler | 15–0 | Corky Nelson | NSNS |
| 1974 | Thomasville, GA | 12–1 | Jim Hughes | NSNS |
| 1975 | Los Angeles, CA, Loyola | 13–0 | Marty Shaughnessy | NSNS |
| Rancho Cordova, CA, Cordova | 12–0 | Dewey Guerra | NSNS |
| 1976 | Cincinnati, OH, Moeller | 12–0 | Gerry Faust | NSNS |
| Warner Robins, Warner Robins, Ga. | 13–0 | Robert Davis | NSNS |
| 1977 | Cincinnati, OH, Moeller | 12–0 | Gerry Faust | NSNS |
| 1978 | Annandale, VA | 14–0 | Bob Hardage | NSNS |
| Houston, TX, Stratford | 15–0 | Oscar Cripps | NSNS |
| 1979 | Cincinnati, OH, Moeller | 12–0 | Gerry Faust | NSNS |
| 1980 | Cincinnati, OH, Moeller | 13–0 | Gerry Faust | NSNS |
| 1981 | Warner Robins, GA | 15–0 | Robert Davis | NSNS |
| 1982 | Cincinnati, OH, Moeller | 13–0 | Steve Klonne[4] | NSNS, USA |
| 1983 | Berwick Area, PA | 13–0 | George Curry | NSNS, USA |
| 1984 | Valdosta, GA | 15–0 | Nick Hyder | NSNS, USA |
| 1985 | East St. Louis Flyers | 14–0 | Bob Shannon | NSNS, USA |
| 1986 | Valdosta, GA | 15–0 | Nick Hyder | NSNS, USA |
| 1987 | Fontana, CA | 14–0 | Dick Bruich | NPP |
| Pittsburgh, PA, North Hills | 13–0 | Jack McCurry | USA |
| Plano, TX | 16–0 | Gerald Brence | NSNS |
| 1988 | Pensacola, FL, Pine Forest | 14–0 | Carl Madison | NSNS, USA |
| Prichard, AL, Vigor | 13–0 | Harold Clark | NPP |
| 1989 | Cleveland, OH, St. Ignatius | 13–0 | Chuck Kyle | USA |
| Odessa, TX, Permian | 16–0 | Gary Gaines | NPP, NSNS |
| 1990 | Houston, TX, Aldine | 15–0 | Bill Smith | NPP |
| Lawton, OK, Eisenhower | 14–0 | Tim Reynolds | USA |
| Ruston, LA | 14–0 | Jimmy "Chick" Childress | NSNS |
| 1991 | Indianapolis, IN, Ben Davis | 14–0 | Dick Dullaghan | NPP, NSNS |
| LaGrange, GA | 15–0 | Gary Guthrie | USA |
| 1992 | Berwick Area, PA | 15–0 | George Curry | USA |
| Valdosta, GA | 14–0 | Nick Hyder | NPP, NSNS |
| 1993 | Cleveland, OH, St. Ignatius | 14–0 | Chuck Kyle | NPP, NSNS, USA |
| 1994 | Concord, CA, De La Salle | 13–0 | Bob Ladouceur | NPP, NSNS |
| Santa Ana, CA, Mater Dei | 14–0 | Bruce Rollinson | USA |
| 1995 | Berwick Area, PA | 15–0 | George Curry | USA |
| Cleveland, OH, St. Ignatius | 14–0 | Chuck Kyle | NPP, NSNS |
| 1996 | Hampton, VA | 14–0 | Mike Smith | NPP, NSNS |
| Santa Ana, CA, Mater Dei | 14–0 | Bruce Rollinson | USA |
| 1997 | Canton, OH, McKinley | 14–0 | Thom McDaniels | USA |
| Hampton, VA | 13–0 | Mike Smith | NPP, NSNS |
| 1998 | Concord, CA, De La Salle | 12–0 | Bob Ladouceur | NPP, NSNS, USA |
| 1999 | Concord, CA, De La Salle | 12–0 | Bob Ladouceur | NSNS |
| Midland, TX, Lee | 15–0 | John Parchman | USA |
| Shreveport, LA, Evangel Christian | 15–0 | Dennis Dunn | NPP |
| 2000 | Concord, CA, De La Salle | 13–0 | Bob Ladouceur | NPP, USA, NSNS |
| 2001 | Concord, CA, De La Salle | 12–0 | Bob Ladouceur | NPP, USA, NSNS |
| 2002 | Concord, CA, De La Salle | 13–0 | Bob Ladouceur | NPP, USA, NSNS |
| 2003 | Concord, CA, De La Salle | 13–0 | Bob Ladouceur | NPP, USA, NSNS |
| 2004 | Southlake, TX, Carroll | 16–0 | Todd Dodge | NPP, USA, NSNS |
| Cincinnati, OH, Colerain | 15–0 | Kerry Coombs | Freeman |
| 2005 | Lakeland, FL | 15–0 | Bill Castle | USA |
| Southlake, TX, Carroll | 16–0 | Todd Dodge | NPP, Freeman, NSNS |
| 2006 | Lakeland, FL | 15–0 | Bill Castle | NPP, NSNS, ESPN |
| Southlake, TX, Carroll | 16–0 | Todd Dodge | USA, Freeman |
| 2007 | Cincinnati, OH, St. Xavier | 15–0 | Steve Specht | NPP, Freeman, ESPN |
| Miami, FL, Northwestern | 15–0 | Billy Rolle | USA, NSNS |
| 2008 | Fort Lauderdale, FL, St. Thomas Aquinas | 15–0 | George Smith | NPP, USA, Freeman, Xcellent 25, NSNS, ESPN |
| 2009 | Ramsey, NJ, Don Bosco Prep | 12–0 | Greg Toal | NPP, USA, Freeman, Xcellent 25, NSNS, ESPN |
| 2010 | Fort Lauderdale, FL, St. Thomas Aquinas | 15–0 | George Smith | NPP, NSNS, ESPN |
| South Panola, MS | 15–0 | Lance Pogue | USA, Freeman |
| Concord, CA, De La Salle | 14–0 | Bob Ladouceur | Xcellent 25 |
| 2011 | Ramsey, NJ, Don Bosco Prep | 11–0 | Greg Toal | NPP, USA, Freeman, Xcellent 25, NSNS, ESPN |
| 2012 | River Ridge, LA, John Curtis Christian | 14-0 | J.T. Curtis | NPP, USA, Xcellent 25, HSFA |
| Concord, CA, De La Salle | 15–0 | Bob Ladouceur | Freeman, ESPN |
| Katy, TX | 16–0 | Gary Joseph | NSNS |
| 2013 | St. John Bosco High School | 15–0 | Jason Negro | Freeman |
| Allen, TX | 16–0 | Tom Westerberg | HSFA |
| Booker T. Washington High School | 14–0 | Tim "Ice" Harris | USA, Xcellent 25, NPP, NSNS |
| 2014 | Las Vegas, NV, Bishop Gorman | 15–0 | Tony Sanchez | NPP, USA |
| Allen, TX | 16–0 | Tom Westerberg | Xcellent 25, NSNS, HSFA |
| Concord, CA, De La Salle | 14–0 | Justin Alumbaugh | Freeman |
| 2015 | Katy, TX | 16–0 | Gary Joseph | NPP, Xcellent 25 |
| Moultrie, GA, Colquitt County | 15–0 | Rush Propst | HSFA, Freeman |
| Las Vegas, NV, Bishop Gorman | 15–0 | Kenny Sanchez | USA |
| 2016 | Las Vegas, NV, Bishop Gorman | 15–0 | Kenny Sanchez | NPP, USA, Freeman, HSFA, Xcellent 25 |
| 2017 | Santa Ana, CA, Mater Dei | 15–0 | Bruce Rollinson | NPP, USA, HSFA, Freeman, Xcellent 25 |
| 2018 | Santa Ana, CA, Mater Dei | 13–2 | Bruce Rollinson | USA, HSFA, Freeman |
| Houston, TX, North Shore | 16–0 | Jon Kay | Xcellent 25, NPP |
| 2019 | Fort Lauderdale, FL, St. Thomas Aquinas | 15-0 | Roger Harriott | GEICO |
| Bellflower, CA, St. John Bosco | 13-1 | Jason Negro | NPP, USA, HSFA, Freeman, Xcellent 25 |
| 2020 | Bradenton, FL, IMG Academy | 8–0 | Bobby Acosta | Xcellent 25, USA, HSFA |