| Year | Winner(s) | Album | Artist | Nominees (Artist in parentheses) |
| 2019 | Julian Burg, Serban Ghenea, David Greenbaum, John Hanes, Beck Hansen, Greg Kurstin, Florian Lagatta, Cole M.G.N., Alex Pasco, Jesse Shatkin, Darrell Thorp & Cassidy Turbin (engineers); Chris Bellman, Tom Coyne, Emily Lazar & Randy Merrill (mastering engineers) | Colors | Beck | - Earthtones (Bahamas) — Robbie Lackritz (engineer); Philip Shaw Bova (mastering engineer)
- All The Things That I Did And All The Things That I Didn't Do (The Milk Carton Kids) — Ryan Freeland & Kenneth Pattengale (engineers); Kim Rosen (mastering engineer)
- Head Over Heels (Chromeo) — Nathaniel Alford, Jason Evigan, Chris Galland, Tom Gardner, Patrick "P-Thugg" Gemayel, Serban Ghenea, John Hanes, Tony Hoffer, Derek Keota, Ian Kirkpatrick, David Macklovitch, Amber Mark, Manny Marroquin, Vaughn Oliver, Chris "TEK" O'Ryan, Morgan Taylor Reid & Gian Stone (engineers); Chris Gehringer & Michelle Mancini (mastering engineers)
- Voicenotes (Charlie Puth) — Manny Marroquin & Charlie Puth (engineers); Dave Kutch (mastering engineer)
|
| 2018 | Serban Ghenea, John Hanes & Charles Moniz, engineers; Tom Coyne, mastering engineer | 24K Magic | Bruno Mars | - Every Where Is Some Where (K. Flay) — Brent Arrowood, Miles Comaskey, JT Daly, Tommy English, Kristine Flaherty, Adam Hawkins, Chad Howat & Tony Maserati, engineers; Joe LaPorta, mastering engineer
- Is This the Life We Really Want? (Roger Waters) — Nigel Godrich, Sam Petts-Davies & Darrell Thorp, engineers; Bob Ludwig, mastering engineer
- Natural Conclusion (Rose Cousins) — Ryan Freeland, engineer; Joao Carvalho, mastering engineer
- No Shape (Perfume Genius) — Shawn Everett & Joseph Lorge, engineers; Patricia Sullivan, mastering engineer
|
| 2017 | David Bowie, Tom Elmhirst, Kevin Killen & Tony Visconti, engineers; Joe LaPorta, mastering engineer | Blackstar | David Bowie | - Are You Serious (Andrew Bird) — Tchad Blake & David Boucher, engineers; Bob Ludwig, mastering engineer
- Dig in Deep (Bonnie Raitt) — Ryan Freeland, engineer; Kim Rosen, mastering engineer
- Hit n Run Phase Two (Prince) — Booker T., Dylan Dresdow, Chris James, Prince & Justin Stanley, engineers; Dylan Dresdow, mastering engineer
- Undercurrent (Sarah Jarosz) — Shani Gandhi & Gary Paczosa, engineers; Paul Blakemore, mastering engineer
|
| 2016 | Shawn Everett, engineer; Bob Ludwig, mastering engineer | Sound & Color | Alabama Shakes | - Before This World (James Taylor) — Dave O'Donnell, engineer; Ted Jensen, mastering engineer
- Currency of Man (Melody Gardot) — Maxime Le Guil, engineer; Bernie Grundman, mastering engineer
- Recreational Love (The Bird and the Bee) — Greg Kurstin & Alex Pasco, engineers; Emily Lazar, mastering engineer
- Wallflower (Diana Krall) — Steve Price, Jochem van der Saag & Jorge Vivo, engineers; Paul Blakemore, mastering engineer
|
| 2015 | Tom Elmhirst, Cole M. Greif-Neill, David Greenbaum, Florian Lagatta, Cole Marsden, Robbie Nelson, Darrell Thorp, Cassidy Turbin & Joe Visciano, engineers; Bob Ludwig, mastering engineer | Morning Phase | Beck | - Bass & Mandolin (Chris Thile & Edgar Meyer) — Richard King & Dave Sinko, engineers; Bob Ludwig, mastering engineer
- Bluesamericana (Keb' Mo') — Ross Hogarth & Casey Wasner, engineers; Richard Dodd, mastering engineer
- The Way I'm Livin' (Lee Ann Womack) — Chuck Ainlay, engineer; Gavin Lurssen, mastering engineer
- What's Left Is Forever (Thomas Dybdahl) — Tchad Blake, Oyvind Jakobsen, Jo Ranheim, Itai Shapiro & Davi Way, engineers; Bernie Grundman, mastering engineer
|
| 2014 | Peter Franco, Mick Guzauski, Daniel Lerner & Florian Lagatta, engineers; Bob Ludwig & Antoine Chabert, mastering engineers | Random Access Memories | Daft Punk | - Annie Up (Pistol Annies) — Chuck Ainlay, engineer; Bob Ludwig, mastering engineer
- The Blue Room (Madeleine Peyroux) — Helik Hadar & Leslie Ann Jones, engineers; Bernie Grundman, mastering engineer
- The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here (Alice in Chains) — Paul Figueroa & Randy Staub, engineers; Ted Jensen, mastering engineer
- ...Like Clockwork (Queens of the Stone Age) — Joe Barresi & Mark Rankin, engineers; Gavin Lurssen, mastering engineer
- The Moorings (Andrew Duhon) — Trina Shoemaker, engineer; Eric Conn, mastering engineer
|
| 2013 | Richard King, engineer & mastering engineer | The Goat Rodeo Sessions | Yo-Yo Ma, Stuart Duncan, Edgar Meyer & Chris Thile | - The Absence (Melody Gardot) — Moogie Canazio & Al Schmitt, engineers; Bernie Grundman, mastering engineer
- Ashes & Fire (Ryan Adams) — Glyn Johns, engineer; Bob Ludwig, mastering engineer
- Love Is a Four Letter Word (Jason Mraz) — Joe Chiccarelli, Steve Churchyard, Tony Maserati, Lars Fox, Graham Hope & Morgan Stratton, engineers; Bob Ludwig, mastering engineer
- Slingshot (Rebecca Pidgeon) — Helik Hadar, engineer; Bernie Grundman, mastering engineer
|
| 2012 | Mike Shipley & Neal Cappellino, engineers; Brad Blackwood, mastering engineer | Paper Airplane | Alison Krauss & Union Station | - Follow Me Down (Sarah Jarosz) — Brandon Bell & Gary Paczosa, engineers; Sangwook "Sunny" Nam & Doug Sax, mastering engineers
- The Harrow & The Harvest (Gillian Welch) — Matt Andrews, engineer; Stephen Marcussen, mastering engineer
- Music Is Better Than Words (Seth MacFarlane) — Rich Breen & Frank Filipetti, engineers; Bob Ludwig, mastering engineer
- The Next Right Thing (Seth Glier) — Kevin Killen, Brendan Muldowney & John Shyloski, engineers; John Shyloski, mastering engineer
|
| 2011 | Michael H. Brauer, Joe Ferla, Chad Franscoviak & Manny Marroquin, engineers | Battle Studies | John Mayer | |
| 2010 | Imogen Heap, engineer | Ellipse | Imogen Heap | - Gossip in the Grain (Ray LaMontagne) — Ethan Johns & Dominic Monks, engineers
- My One and Only Thrill (Melody Gardot) — Helik Hadar & Al Schmitt, engineers
- Safe Trip Home (Dido) — Jon Brion, Jim Scott, Grippa & Greg Koller, engineers
- Swan Feathers (Leslie Mendelson) — Richard Alderson, Chris Allen, Roman Klun, Jamie Polaski, Lawrence Manchester, Rob Mounsey, Jay Newland, Gene Paul & Gordie Sampson, engineers
|