| Year | Winner(s) | Work | Performer(s) | Nominees | Ref. |
| 1959 | Frank Sinatra | Frank Sinatra Sings for Only the Lonely | Frank Sinatra | | [1] |
| 1959 | Robert M. Jones | Shostakovich: Symphony No. 5 | Howard Mitchell (conducting the National Symphony Orchestra) | | [2] |
| 1961 | Marvin Schwartz | Latin ala Lee! | Peggy Lee | | [3] |
| 1962 – Other Than Classical | Jim Silke | Judy at Carnegie Hall | Judy Garland | | [4] |
| 1962 – Classical | Marvin Schwartz | Puccini: Madame Butterfly | Marvin Schwartz | | [4] |
| 1963 – Other Than Classical | Robert M. Jones | Lena... Lovely and Alive | Lena Horne | | [5] |
| 1963 – Classical | Marvin Schwartz | The Intimate Bach | Marvin Schwartz | | [5] |
| 1964 – Other Than Classical | John Berg | The Barbra Streisand Album | Barbra Streisand | - Robert M. Jones for Aloha from Norman Luboff, performed by Norman Luboff Choir
- Robert M. Jones for Honey in the Horn, performed by Al Hirt
- Jim Ladwig for Bach's Greatest Hits, performed by The Swingle Singers
- John Murello for Night Train, performed by Oscar Peterson
- Jim Silke for Hollywood My Way, performed by Nancy Wilson
- Edward L. Thrasher for Carl Reiner and Mel Brooks at the Cannes Film Festival, performed by Carl Reiner and Mel Brooks
| [6] |
| 1964 – Classical | Robert M. Jones | Puccini: Madama Butterfly | Robert M. Jones | | [6] |
| 1965 – Other Than Classical | Robert Cato and Don Bronstein | People | Barbra Streisand | - Robert Cato and Milton Glaser for The Sound of Harlem, performed by Various Artists
- John Murello and Olga Albizu for Getz/Gilberto, performed by Stan Getz and João Gilberto
- George Osak and George Jerman for Guitar From Ipanema, performed by Laurindo Almeida
- Ed Thrasher for Poitier Meets Plato, performed by Sidney Poitier
| [7] |
| 1965 – Classical | Robert M. Jones and Jan Balet | Saint-Saëns: Carnival of the Animals/Britten: Young Person's Guide to the Orchestra | Arthur Fiedler conducting the Boston Pops | | [7] |
| 1966 – Graphic Arts | George Estes and James Alexander | Bartók: Concerto No. 2 for Violin/Stravinsky: Concerto for Violin | Joseph Silverstein & Erich Leinsdorf conducting the Boston Symphony Orchestra | - John Berg for Horowitz at Carnegie Hall, performed by Vladimir Horowitz
- John Berg for William Tell and Other Favorite Overtures, performed by Leonard Bernstein conducting the New York Philharmonic
- Georges Estes and Charles White for Gould: Spirituals for Orchestra/Copland: Dance Symphony, performed by Morton Gould conducting the Chicago Symphony
- Jerry Smokler and Paul Davis for Solo Monk, performed by Thelonious Monk
- Ed Thrasher and Patrick Blackwell for Concert in the Virgin Islands, performed by Duke Ellington
| [8] |
| 1966 – Photography | Robert M. Jones and Ken Whitmore | Jazz Suite on the Mass Texts | Paul Horn | | [8] |
| 1967 – Graphic Arts | Klaus Voormann | Revolver | The Beatles | | [9] |
| 1967 – Photography | Robert M. Jones and Les Leverette | Confessions of a Broken Man | Porter Wagoner | - Bob Cato, John Berg, and Gerald Schatsberg for Blonde on Blonde, performed by Bob Dylan
- Bob Cato, John Berg, and Guy Webster for Turn! Turn! Turn!, performed by The Byrds
- Robert M. Jones and Tom Zimmerman for The Time Machine, performed by Gary Burton
- Ed Thrasher and Tom Tucker for Sammy Davis, Jr. Sings and Laurindo Almeida Plays, performed by Sammy Davis, Jr. and Laurindo Almeida
- Peter Whorf for Guantanamera, performed by The Sandpipers
- Peter Whorf and George Jerman for What Now My Love, performed by Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass
| [9] |
| 1968 – Graphic Arts | Peter Blake and Jann Haworth | Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band | The Beatles | - John Berg, Bob Cato, and Henrietta Condak for Haydn: Symphony No. 84 in E Flat Major/Symphony No. 85 in B Flat Major ("La Reine"), performed by Leonard Bernstein conducting the New York Philharmonic
- John Berg, Bob Cato, and Lasio Kubinyi for Straight No Chaser, performed by Thelonious Monk
- Robert M. Jones and Jack Davis for Nashville Cats, performed by Homer and Jethro
- Ed Thrasher and Charles White for The Gold Standard Collection, performed by Hank Thompson
- Woody Woodward and Wayne Kimball for Up, Up and Away, performed by The 5th Dimension
| [10] |
| 1968 – Photography | John Berg, Bob Cato, and Rowland Scherman | Bob Dylan's Greatest Hits | Bob Dylan | - Bill Harvey, Guy Webster, and Joel Brodsky for The Doors, performed by The Doors
- Robert M. Jones and Jimmy Moore for Suburban Attitudes in Country Verse, performed by John Loudermilk
- Robert M. Jones and New World Photography for Earthwords & Music, performed by John Hartford
- Robert M. Jones and Howard Cooper for From Mexico with Laughs, performed by Don Bowman
- Ken Kim for Bravo, Bravo, Aznavour, performed by Charles Aznavour
- Ken Kim for That Man, Robert Mitchum Sings, performed by Robert Mitchum
| [10] |
| 1969 | John Berg, Richard Mantel, and Horn/Griner Studio | Underground | Thelonious Monk | | [11] |
| 1970 | Evelyn J. Kelbish and David Stahlberg | America the Beautiful | Gary McFarland | - Gary Burden and Henry Diltz for Richard Pryor, performed by Richard Pryor
- David Juniper for Led Zeppelin II, performed by Led Zeppelin
- Tom Lazarus, Gene Brownell, and Bill Gordon for Pidgeon, performed by Pidgeon
- Bob Seidman for Blind Faith, performed by Blind Faith
| [12] |
| 1971 | Robert Lockhart and Ivan Nagy | Indianola Mississippi Seeds | B. B. King | - John Berg and Nick Fasciano for Chicago, performed by Chicago
- John Berg, Philip Hays, Lloyd Ziff for The World's Greatest Blues Singer, performed by Bessie Smith
- Ed Thrasher and Dave Bhang for Hand Made, performed by Mason Williams
- Desmond Strobel and John Craig for The Naked Carmen, performed by Various Artists
- Peter Whorf, Martin Donald, and Christopher Whorf for Mason Proffit, performed by Mason Proffit
- Peter Whorf, Christopher Whorf, and Fred Poore for Schubert: "Unfinished" Symphony/ Beethoven: Fifth Symphony, performed by Artur Rodziński conducting the Philharmonic Symphony Orchestra of London
- Woody Woodward, William E. McEuen, and Dean O. Torrence for Uncle Charlie and His Dog Teddy, performed by Nitty Gritty Dirt Band
| [13] |
| 1972 | Gene Brownell and Dean O. Torrence | Pollution | Pollution | - John Berg, Robert Lockhart, and Norman Seeff for Blood, Sweat & Tears 4, performed by Blood, Sweat & Tears
- Vincent J. Biondi and Susan Obrant for The Music of Erik Satie: Through a Looking Glass, performed by Camarata Contemporary Chamber Orchestra
- Acy Lehman and Nick Sangiamo for Bark, performed by Jefferson Airplane
- Norman Seeff and John Van Hammersveld, for Black Pearl, performed by Jimmy McGriff
- Ed Thrasher and John Van Hammersveld for Hot Platters, performed by Various Artists
- Ed Thrasher and Terry Paul for Sharepickers, performed by Mason Williams
- Craig Braun and Andy Warhol for Sticky Fingers, performed by The Rolling Stones
| [14] |
| 1973 | Acy Lehman and Harvey Dinnerstein | The Siegel-Schwall Band | The Siegel-Schwall Band | - Hipgnosis and Poe for Flash, performed by Flash
- Ron Levine and Pacific Eye & Ear for Five Dollar Shoes, performed by Five Dollar Shoes
- Bill Levy and Fred Marcellino for Virgin, performed by The Mission
- Aaron Schumaker and Tumbleweed Graphics for Chief, performed by Dewey Terry
- Norman Seeff for Historical Figures and Ancient Heads, performed by Canned Heat
- Ed Thrasher, Chris Wolf, Dave Willardson, and John & Barbara Casado for Sunset Ride, performed by Zephyr
- Wilkes & Braun, Sound Packing Corp., and Robert Otter for School's Out, performed by Alice Cooper
| [15] |
| 1974 | Wilkes & Braun | Tommy | London Symphony Orchestra and Chambre Choir | | [16] |
| 1975 | Ed Thrasher and Christopher Whorf | Come & Gone | Mason Proffit | | [17] |
| 1976 | Jim Ladwig | Honey | Ohio Players | | [18] |
| 1977 | John Berg | Chicago X | Chicago | | [19] |
| 1978 | John Berg | Love Notes | Ramsey Lewis | | [20] |
| 1979 | Johnny Lee and Tony Lane | Boys in the Trees | Carly Simon | - John Berg and Paula Scher for Heads, performed by Bob James
- Ron Coro for The Cars, performed by The Cars
- Ron Coro and Johnny Lee for Out of the Woods, performed by Oregon
- Gribitt and Tim Bryant for Last Kiss, performed by Fandango
- Tony Lane for Bruce Roberts, performed by Bruce Roberts
- Juni Osaki for Children of Sanchez, performed by Chuck Mangione
- Barbara Wojirsch for Non-Fiction, performed by Steve Kuhn
| [21] |
| 1980 | Mike Doud and Mick Haggerty | Breakfast in America | Supertramp | | [22] |
| 1981 | Roy Kohara | Against the Wind | Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band | | [23] |
| 1982 | Peter Corriston | Tattoo You | The Rolling Stones | | [24] |
| 1983 | Kosh and Ron Larson | Get Closer | Linda Ronstadt | - Jules Bates for Nothing to Fear, performed by Oingo Boingo
- Mick Haggerty and Ginger Canzoneri for Vacation, performed by The Go-Go's
- Denise Minobe and Ron Coro for We Are One, performed by Pieces of a Dream
- George Osaki for Ongaku-Kai Live in Japan, performed by The Crusaders
| [25] |
| 1984 | Robert Rauschenberg | Speaking in Tongues | Talking Heads | | [26] |
| 1985 | Janet Perr | She's So Unusual | Cyndi Lauper | | [27] |
| 1986 | Kosh and Ron Larson | Lush Life | Linda Ronstadt | | [28] |
| 1987 | Eiko Ishioka | Tutu | Miles Davis | | [29] |
| 1988 | Bill Johnson | King's Record Shop | Rosanne Cash | - Peter Barratett for Shaka Zulu, performed by Ladysmith Black Mambazo
- Bruce Licher for Echelons, performed by For Against
- Ron Scarselli for Document, performed by R.E.M.
- Joe Stelmach for The Webster Blanton Band, performed by Duke Ellington
| [30] |
| 1989 | Bill Johnson | Tired of the Runnin | The O'Kanes | | [31] |
| 1990 | Roger Gorman | Sound + Vision | David Bowie | - Bill Burks and Tommy Steele for Foreign Affair, performed by Tina Turner
- Tom Recchion for Batman, performed by Prince
- Tommy Steele for Monster, performed by Fetchin Bones
- Jimmy Watchel for World in Motion, performed by Jackson Browne
| [32] |
| 1991 | Len Peltier, Jeff Gold, and Suzanne Vega | Days of Open Hand | Suzanne Vega | | [33] |
| 1992 | Vartan | The Complete Decca Recordings | Billie Holiday | | [34] |
| 1993 | Melanie Nissen | Spellbound | Paula Abdul | - Geoff Gans for Queen of Soul: The Atlantic Recordings, performed by Aretha Franklin
- Tommy Steele, Stephen Walker for Too Legit to Quit, performed by MC Hammer
- Ria Lewerke and Norman Moore for The King of Rock 'n' Roll: The Complete 50s Masters, performed by Elvis Presley
- Len Peltier for 99.9F°, performed by Suzanne Vega
| [35] |
| 1994 | David Lau | The Complete Billie Holiday on Verve 1945–1959 | Billie Holiday | | [36] |
| 1995 | Buddy Jackson | Tribute to the Music of Bob Willis and the Texas Playboys | Asleep at the Wheel | | [37] |
| 1996 | Robbie Cavolina and Joni Mitchell | Turbulent Indigo | Joni Mitchell | | [38] |
| 1997 | Andy Engel and Tommy Steele | Ultra-Lounge (Leopard Skin Sampler) | Various Artists | | [39] |
| 1998 | Hugh Brown, Al Q, and Jeff Smith | Titanic: Music As Heard on the Fateful Voyage | Various Artists | | [40] |
| 1999 | Kevin Reagan | Ray of Light | Madonna | | [41] |
| 2000 | Ray Benson, Sally Carns, and Buddy Jackson | Ride With Bob | Asleep at the Wheel | - Carla Leighton for Bleecker Street: Greenwich Village in the 1960s, performed by Various Artists
- Tammy Dotson, Michael Hodgson, and Clive Piercy for Late Night Sessions, performed by Caravana Cubana
- Brad Benedict, Andy Engel, Johnny Lee, and Tommy Steele for Ultra-Lounge: Tiki Sampler, performed by Various Artists
- Joseph Arthur and Zachary Larner for Vacancy, performed by Joseph Arthur
| [42] |
| 2001 | Kevin Reagan | Music | Madonna | | [44] |
| 2002 | Stanley Donwood and Tchocky | Amnesiac (Special Limited Edition) | Radiohead | | [45] |
| 2003 | Kevin Reagan | Home | Dixie Chicks | | [46] |
| 2004 | Ani DiFranco and Brian Grunert | Evolve | Ani DiFranco | | [47] |
| 2005 | Peter Buchanan-Smith and Dan Nadel | A Ghost Is Born | Wilco | | [48] |
| 2006 | Aimee Mann and Gail Marowitz | The Forgotten Arm | Aimee Mann | | [49] |
| 2007 | Adam Jones | 10,000 Days | Tool | | [50] |
| 2008 | Zachary Nipper | Cassadaga | Bright Eyes | | [51] |
| 2009 | Metallica | Death Magnetic | Metallica | - Don Clark for Hawk Nelson Is My Friend, performed by Hawk Nelson
- No Age and Brian Roettinger for Nouns
- Neal Ashby, Matthew Curry, and Patrick Donohue for Radio Retaliation
- Amanda Barrett, Abby DeWald, Renee Jablow, and Rick Whitmore for Summer Rains
| [52] |
| 2010 | Stefan Sagmeister | Everything That Happens Will Happen Today | David Byrne & Brian Eno | - Brian Porizek for Back from the Dead, performed by Spinal Tap
- Neko Case and Kathleen Judge for Middle Cyclone, performed by Neko Case
- Jeff Harrison for Splitting Adam, performed by Splitting Adam
- Szu Wei Cheng and Hui Chen Huang for Tathagata, performed by Various Artists
| [53] |
| 2011 | Michael Carney | Brothers | The Black Keys | - Malene Mathiasson, Malthe Fischer, Kristoffer Rom, Nis Svoldgård, and Aske Zidore for Eggs, performed by Oh No Ono
- Brian Grunert, Anaïs Mitchell, and Peter Nevins for Hadestown, performed by Anaïs Mitchell
- Devendra Banhart and Jon Beasley for What Will We Be, performed by Devendra Banhart
- Andrew Taray for Yonkers NY, performed by Chip Taylor
| [54] |
| 2012 | Caroline Robert | The Suburbs (Deluxe)[55] | Arcade Fire | - Todd Gallopo for Chickenfoot III, performed by Chickenfoot
- Sarah Dodds and Shauna Dodds for Good Luck & True Love, performed by Reckless Kelly
- Jonathan Dagan and Steven Acres for Rivers and Homes, performed by J.Viewz
- Vincent Morisset for The Suburbs (Deluxe), performed by Arcade Fire (Note: the Nominees list credited this nomination to Vincent Morisset, but for reasons unknown the award was given to Caroline Robert)
- Virgil Abloh for Watch The Throne, performed by Jay-Z and Kanye West
| [56] |
| 2013 | Michael Amzalag & Mathias Augustyniak | Biophilia | Björk | - Brett Kilroe for Boys & Girls, performed by the Alabama Shakes
- Gail Marowitz for Charmer, performed by Aimee Mann
- Noah Wall for Love This Giant, performed by David Byrne & St. Vincent
- David Longstreth for Swing Lo Magellan, performed by Dirty Projectors
| [57] |
| 2014 | Sarah Dodds and Shauna Dodds | Long Night Moon | Reckless Kelly | - Mike Brown, Zac Decamp, Brian Grunert & Annie Stoll for Automatic Music Can Be Fun, performed by Geneseo
- Brian Roettinger for Magna Carta...Holy Grail, performed by Jay Z
- Bruce Duckworth, Sarah Moffat & David Turner for Metallica Through the Never, performed by Metallica
- Jonathan Barnbrook for The Next Day, performed by David Bowie
| [58] |
| 2015 | Jeff Ament, Don Pendleton, Joe Spix, and Jerome Turner | Lightning Bolt | Pearl Jam | - David Chen & Andrew Wong for Formosa Medicine Show, performed by The Muddy Basin Ramblers
- Vaughan Oliver for Indie Cindy, performed by Pixies
- Jesse Kanda for LP1, performed by FKA twigs
- Sarah Larnach for Whispers, performed by Passenger
| [59] |
| 2016 | Sarah Dodds, Shauna Dodds & Dick Reeves | Still the King: Celebrating the Music of Bob Wills and His Texas Playboys | Asleep at the Wheel | - Alex Trochut for Alagoas, performed by Alagoas
- Anita Marisa Boriboon & Phi Hollinger for Bush, performed by Snoop Dogg
- Brian Roettinger for How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful (Deluxe Edition), performed by Florence + The Machine
- Nathanio Strimpopulos for My Happiness, performed by Elvis Presley
| [60] |
| 2017 | Jonathan Barnbrook | Blackstar | David Bowie | - Roy Nachum, Ciarra Pardo & Rihanna for Anti (Deluxe Edition), performed by Rihanna
- Andrew Savage for Human Performance, performed by Parquet Courts
- Sarah Dodds & Shauna Dodds for Sunset Motel, performed by Reckless Kelly
- Eric Timothy Carlson for 22, A Million, performed by Bon Iver
| [61] |
| 2018 | TIE: Carlos Dussan, Juliana Jaramillo, Juan Martinez & Claudio Roncoli / Sasha Barr, Ed Steed & Josh Tillman | TIE: El Orisha De La Rosa / Pure Comedy (Deluxe Edition) | TIE: Magín Díaz / Father John Misty | - Alex Crossan & Matt De Jong for Mura Masa, performed by Mura Masa
- Elyanna Blaser-Gould, Luke Hayman & Andrea Trabucco-Campos for Sleep Well Beast, performed by The National
- Gail Marowitz for Solid State, performed by Jonathan Coulton
| [62] |
| 2019 | Willo Perron | Masseduction | St. Vincent | - Mary Banas for Be the Cowboy, performed by Mitski
- Joseph Pekara for “Window“, performed by Nappy Roots
- Joseph Pekara for “Til They Told Us“ performed by Nappy Roots
- HuskyFox for Love Yourself: Tear, performed by BTS
- Qing-Yang Xiao for The Offering, performed by The Chairman
- Adam Moore for Well Kept Thing, performed by Foxhole
| [63] |
| 2020 | Barry Ament, Jeff Ament, & Joe Spix | Chris Cornell | Chris Cornell | - Luisa María Arango, Carlos Dussan, Manuel García-Orozco & Juliana Jaramillo-Buenaventura for Anónimas & Resilientes, performed by the Voces del Bullerengue
- Andrew Wong & Fongming Yang for Hold That Tiger, performed by The Muddy Basin Ramblers
- Aaron Anderson & Eric Timothy Carlson for I,I, performed by Bon Iver
- Irwan Awalludin for Intellexual, performed by Intellexual
| [64] |
| 2021 | Winner TBA on 31 January 2021 | | | - Pilar Zeta for Everyday Life (Coldplay)
- Kyle Goen for Funeral (Lil Wayne)
- Julian Gross & Hannah Hooper for Healer (Grouplove)
- Jordan Butcher for On Circles (Caspian)
- Doug Cunningham & Jason Noto for Vols. 11 & 12 (Desert Sessions)
| [65] |